How Green is Green in Landscape Architecture? By Christine Rombouts, freelance writer, West Coast real estate industry![]() The outdoor living space for this home in the new Alamo Creek development in Danville, Calif., San Francisco East Bay, is surrounded by locally sourced permeable cobbles (3/8" ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Black & White?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,??) and tile pavers (12" x 12" ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Blue Black?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,?? American slate). The brick paving is ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Georgetown?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,?? in a herringbone pattern. The BBQ counter is in brick, with a stucco finish that matches the home?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,??s exterior, and incorporates 6" x 6" ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Blue Black?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,?? tiles. The center pot is a ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Black Matte?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,?? color (Gainey). Not seen here is an adjacent artificial turf area. All images courtesy of NUVIS landscape architecture and planning. |
What should landscape architects do when faced with the extreme challenge of planning and building a new community while significantly reducing the use of water that would normally be required for landscaping? From a sustainability point of view, efficient use of water can be achieved a number of ways, including use of drought resistant plants, strategic use of artificial turf, and technology. ![]() The Alamo Creek community incorporates affordable senior housing, townhomes, an elementary school, community park, an aquatic center, a fire station, an artificial turf soccer complex, a bio-retention area, reclaimed and potable water tanks and an onsite weather station. Approximately 275 acres of open space was preserved. First a definition of a ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????native?EUR??,,????'?????<???????? plant:
![]() A rugged look is achieved with locally sourced flagstone paving (Three Rivers) and boulders (6' plus ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Water Wash?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,?? at 2' x 3' x 5' cubic dimension), coupled with native grasses. Using native plants is a key component to a sustainable landscape architecture plan, asserts Leslee Temple, FASLA, vice president of NUVIS, a landscape architecture and planning firm based in Costa Mesa, Calif., with offices in San Ramon, Calif., Las Vegas and Scottsdale, Ariz. Native plants can significantly reduce maintenance costs. To achieve important sustainable or ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????green?EUR??,,????'?????<???????? goals, consider the following advice. Do away with water hungry landscaping in favor of more drought and animal resistant plant materials. This does require some research and you may have to hit a lot of nurseries and suppliers. The best sustainable designs usually have an extensive list of plant materials. ![]() Water elements are used sparingly and in key locations. The ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Croaking Frog?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,?? spitters add interest and movement to the tiled courtyard wall (2" x 2" tiles, National Pool). The appealing ground design is tumbled ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Blue Stone?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,?? pavers of random sizes with a swirl of black Mexican pebbles. Ms. Temple said that it?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,??s important to identify places where water was not really necessary (even though it might go against every instinct you have). These places could be great spots for outdoor fireplaces, fire pits, waterfalls, koi ponds, rock gardens, meditation gardens, and pieces of art. Don?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,??t overlook the benefits of artificial turf?EUR??,,????'?????<???????????your residents may love a putting green. Besides drought resistance landscaping, other water conversation measures include water-control devices on irrigation systems, water-efficient systems inside and outside the home. Toro Intelli-sense ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Smart?EUR??,,????'?????<???????? controllers gather weather data from nearby weather stations. This weather information is used to automatically adjust run times according to the site and plants?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,?? actual requirements, resulting in more efficient water management. With the ET-Everywhere subscription weather, data are gathered from NOAA Weather Satellites and are accurate down to one sq. km., providing the accuracy of an onsite weather station without the cost and maintenance. This is definitely an ideal water conservation tool for residential applications. ![]() Water use calculations allowed only a limited number of pools for the community?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,??s 923 residences. This serene December photograph reveals a pool landscape that is decidedly atypical of residential pools. The pool coping is 4" x 12" ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Noche Ancient?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,?? Durango and wallcap with a 2" x 2" tile striping beneath the raised bond beam of ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Blue Black?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,?? Ledge Stone. The ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Black Marble?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,?? PebbleTec for the pool bottom gives the water an opaque lake look. As water requirements vary, so does maintenance. Extra drainage may be required at certain times of the year, along with minimal overhead sprays. More subsurface or drip techniques are needed when irrigating. Subsurface drip line and drip irrigation eliminate any overspray, thus saving water. These irrigation methods also work well in windy areas providing uniform irrigation. With proper operation, subsurface and drip irrigation use about half of the water of an overhead system. Water is applied directly to the root zone and seasonal plant growth interference is eliminated. In the final analysis, each individual component of the landscape architecture plan?EUR??,,????'?????<??????????? hardscape and softscape?EUR??,,????'?????<???????????makes an esthetic contribution to the whole of your home?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,??s environment while still protecting the earth?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,??s environment. ![]() ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Red Slate?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,?? tiles (12" x 12", Siena Tile & Stone) are juxtaposed with a seating area of ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Purple?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,?? tiles (16" x 16", American Slate) with a natural concrete band. A prefabricated copper firepit is seen between the sofa and chair. The small spa, which can be viewed from the living room, is made of 4 x 4 inch tumbled marble and capped with 12" x 12" tumbled marble ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Rossa Verona.?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,?? Here are a few more key tips from NUVIS:
![]() A front lawn for each home in a new residential development used to be the norm, but the 600-acre Alamo Creek community developed by Shapell Homes had a pact with the East Bay Municipal Utility District of Contra Costa County to significantly reduce irrigation. Hardscapes and native plantings abound. Here there is slate paving (?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Amber Gold?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,??) in thin-set random panels, two to three inch ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Sunburst?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,?? cobbles and a concrete driveway with a salt finish. The ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????turf panels?EUR??,,????'?????<???????? that run up to the garage are the closest you get to lawn. The pot holds Hebes, Cosmos bipinnatus and vinca minor. Lagerstroemia trees are at right. Alamo CreekAn example of where optimum ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????green?EUR??,,????'?????<???????? was used in landscape architecture is the new Alamo Creek community in Danville, Calif. Developer Shapell Homes was faced with the extreme challenge of how to build and market the 600-acre new community, while significantly reducing the use of water that would normally be required for lush lawns, parks and green belts. The solution, according to Ms. Temple, was to go where few landscape architecture firm had ever gone before?EUR??,,????'?????<???????????at least in California. (NUVIS was the landscape architecture and planning firm retained by Shapell Homes to develop and execute this progressive sustainable landscape architecture program.) ![]() The outdoor dining space features a wood arbor and is accented by decorative terra cotta pottery planters and a water element of three prefabricated pots. The ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Mexican Leather?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,?? tile paving 12" x 12" has double rows of brick banding to accent the brick wall. Alamo Creek, which opened for home sale in October 2006, comprises 927 residences with a unique land plan that features an innovative water conservation pact with the East Bay Municipal Utility District (EBMUD) of Contra Costa County. To gain entitlement for the pioneering community, Shapell was required by EBMUD to substantially reduce water usage from levels that would normally be required by a community of Alamo Creek?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,??s size and density. ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Alamo Creek was outside the district?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,??s service boundaries and so the developer didn?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,??t have a dedicated water provider,?EUR??,,????'?????<???????? explains Ms. Temple. ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????To get water for its new community, Shapell had to promise to meet stringent water-use guidelines. ![]() The home celebrates the natural environment?EUR??,,????'?????<???????????simple, beautiful, what you might call California rustic. A flowering Chiltalpa tashkentensis ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Morning Cloud?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,?? tree and Nandina dom. ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Firepower?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,??, Abelia x grandiflora ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Prostrata?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,??, Lavandula sp., and Acacia redolens ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Low Boy?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,?? shrubs complement the concrete pavers. Brick paving with concrete band (Spanish Bond patterns) blends with the bricks steps. The glazed pot shows off ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Brown/Cr????????(R)????me,?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,?? Phormium tenax and annual color. There are a lot of water districts that require water-efficiency, but not to this degree. It forced us to think creatively about landscape design yet at the same time meet market acceptance from home buyers.?EUR??,,????'?????<???????? The program?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,??s primary goal requires zero-net impact on EBMUD?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,??s demand for water and was calculated on a savings basis of two gallons saved for each gallon used by each and every Alamo Creek homeowner. To reach the conservation goal, Shapell Homes and the water utility established efficiency programs incorporating several off-set measures within EBMUD?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,??s service area, including the installation of water saving devices in homes of existing EBMUD residential customers, as well as implementing conservation training programs and other measures to conserve water throughout EBMUD?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,??s service area. ![]() Pottery, tile accents, and drought tolerant plants complement the architecture of the ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Magnolia?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,?? model. Features include stucco pilaster and wall with brick cap, accent tiles, brick steps with stone paving and brick band (24" x 24" ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Oxford?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,?? stone). The wine color glazed 15 gal. entry pot offers Anigozanthus flavidus. The glazed pots atop the pilasters present Nandina dom., Califrachoa and sedum baileyi, with a Lagerstroemia tree at left. Ms. Temple says the firm?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,??s approach was to think outside the proverbial waterbox by identifying places where water was not really necessary, even though it might go against standard operating procedure for residential communities. The starting point was doing away with water hungry natural turf in favor of more drought and animal resistant plant materials for the front yard of each of the community?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,??s 13 model homes. ![]() To meet the zero-net impact on the water demand, front yards forego turf grass for such inviting colorful entries as these lavender varieties and Lagerstroemia trees. The sign reads: ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Shrubs and groundcover with drip irrigation.?EUR??,,????'?????<???????? The brick pilaster and wall have concrete caps, with the brick matching the architecture. The flagstone paving has a concrete band around the steps. A garden bowl (at pilasters) and concrete pots with metal decorative rings add interest. ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????This was a creative challenge,?EUR??,,????'?????<???????? explains Ms. Temple. ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????The planting at each model home was differentiated through a systemic programming of plant varieties in strategically assorted layers to achieve necessary tolerance and desired esthetics. The result was one of the most extensive lists of plant materials we have ever used in any community, but we achieved the goal.?EUR??,,????'?????<???????? Every home has a water budget that residents must honor; they can?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,??t exceed the budget by more than 20 percent or the HOA is assessed a penalty. To assist with monitoring usage, Shapell also installed the Toro Intelli-sense ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Smart?EUR??,,????'?????<???????? controller. ![]() A mix of boulders (?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Water Wash?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,?? 2'-4') and cobble/pebbles (40% ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Noyio?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,?? 1-1/2"; 20% ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Noyio?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,?? 3" x 6"; 20% ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Golden River?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,?? 8" x 12"; 20% ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Golden River?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,?? 1' x 2') has the look of a dry stream bed. The landscape include a Platanus racemosa tree, a Nandina domestica hedge and Muhlenbergia rigens and Miscanthus sinensis ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Morning Light?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,?? grasses. Ric Hendricks, NUVIS principal and manager of its San Ramon office, which supervised the Alamo Creek project, notes that synthetic turf was used in one of the model home?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,??s backyards and on the community soccer fields. ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????We believe this may be one of the most ambitious water conservation programs in California, if not the nation,?EUR??,,????'?????<???????? says Mr. Hendricks. ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????We really pushed the envelope in plant and irrigation design.?EUR??,,????'?????<???????? He notes that drip and subsurface irrigation has been installed in appropriate areas throughout the project, including the model homes, to reduce water consumption. Also, about 95 percent of the landscaped areas for the multifamily town homes are designed with subsurface irrigation. ![]() Meandering sidewalks along the project let walkers enjoy the native species. Trees include Platanus racemosa, Lagerstroemia indica and Prunus c. krauter Vesuvius. Tulbaghia violacea, Abelia x grandiflora ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Prostrata?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,?? and Acacia redolens ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Low Boy?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,?? are the groundcover. All open spaces have been populated with native and regionally adaptive plant species, and will be on a temporary irrigation system that will be closed down once the plant material is established. Turf (native grasses and/or traditional turf) in the model home backyards are irrigated by a subsurface system. More subsurface or drip techniques are used for irrigating, and drip and subsurface irrigation has been designed in appropriate areas to offset water consumption. Subsurface drip line and drip irrigation eliminate any overspray, thus saving water. These irrigation methods also work well in windy areas, providing uniform irrigation. ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????With proper operation, subsurface and drip irrigation use about half of the water of an overhead system,?EUR??,,????'?????<???????? Ms. Temple estimates. ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Water is applied directly to the root zone and seasonal plant growth interference is eliminated.?EUR??,,????'?????<???????? Also, the multifamily housing is designed with about 95 percent of the landscaped area being subsurface irrigation with only the turf play areas using traditional irrigation methods. ![]() Some miss the country living amenity of a front porch. The Alamo development has front yard social areas, a nice deviation from those abrupt thresholds. Tile steps (4" x 8" ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Pearl?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,?? in a running bond patter) lead to exposed aggregate concrete with concrete banding. The tiled (12" x 12") pilasters and fountain half-bowl wall are brick capped to match the brick seat walls. Ms. Temple says she expects other water districts to start requiring these types of tougher mandates. ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????It?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,??s coming and we want to be ahead of the game,?EUR??,,????'?????<???????? she states. ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????East Bay MUD is on the cutting edge.?EUR??,,????'?????<???????? The East Bay Municipal Utility District is now rewriting its ordinances to require the higher levels of sustainability for customers within its service area. Christine Rombouts is a freelance writer. She can be reached at crombouts@cc.rr.com. Alamo Creek, Danville, Calif.Developer/Builder Shapell Homes Landscape architect NUVIS Architecture Robert Hidey Architects Dahlin Group Interior Design Design Tec Creative Design Consultants Michael Trahan Design Design Line Interiors Engineers Civil Engineer: DK Associates Structural Engineer: Borm Associates for Cottonwood Structural Engineer: Gouvis Engineering for Magnolia, Savanna and Willow Development Master-planned community in Danville, Calif. of single-family and attached homes, mixed throughout the project. Total of 680 homes (630 Shapell Homes, 50 Ponderosa Homes). Project includes 127 affordable town homes and 120 affordable senior apartments. Lot sizes vary from 4,000 to 8,000 sq. ft. Ninety-five home lots are in excess of 15,000 sq. ft. Acreage 300 acres of developed space; 300 acres of open space and parks. Environmental Mitigation Approximately 275 acres of open space was preserved, including wetland habitat, enhancement of creek corridors and creation of fully-funded open space management plan for the endangered red legged frog, kit fox and tiger salamander. This open space is slated for preservation and management in perpetuity. Community Amenities New elementary school, parks, regional trails, community center building, with community pool and 10-acre soccer complex. Water Conversation Measures State-of-the-art water conservation community includes:
![]() |