Products, Vendors, CAD Files, Spec Sheets and More...
Sign up for LAWeekly newsletter
Vegetated or living walls and vertical gardens are beginning to get traction in the U.S., thanks mostly to the intriguing vegetated walls of Patrick Blanc that have been popping up around Europe since the 1990s (more on that shortly).
A fair number of websites are now devoted to vegetated walls, including a few companies selling vegetated retaining walls. There are blogs devoted to vegetated walls, including one on the website of the L.A. Times that questioned their viability and utility in the Los Angeles urban environment. https://latimesblogs.latimes.com/home_blog/2010/08/vertical-gardens-skeptic.html
LASN sought the advise of a landscape architect that has studied vegetated walls: April Philips, ASLA, Bay Friendly QP, the principal of April Philips Design Works, Inc. of San Rafael, Calif. She writes a blog for the ASLA Sustainable Design & Development Professional Practice Network (PPN) https://sustainableppn.asla.org/2010/05/24/living-walls-confidential/.
?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Living walls are igniting the imagination of designers everywhere,?EUR??,,????'?????<???????? she writes on her blog. ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????And what is not to like, for as encapsulated visions of nature with their seemingly perfect beauty contained on a wall or screen, they tend to idealize nature in the urban realm??EUR??,,????'?????<????????
First, it?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,??s important to define terms, as the term ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????living walls?EUR??,,????'?????<???????? is being used ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????without a shared understanding?EUR??,,????'?????<???????? of what that means and how they perform, she says. ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Living walls?EUR??,,????'?????<???????? does not mean traditional green facades on stonewall, or solid surfaces with growing vines. Nor does it refer to the new semi-transparent frames for vines as ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????curtains,?EUR??,,????'?????<???????? such as GreenScreen (metal grids) and Jakob (steel cables).
Defining Terms Nigel Dunnett and Noel Kingsbury in Planting Green Roofs and Living Walls define living walls as plants rooted in a growing medium on the outward face of the wall rather than behind the wall facade. ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Hydroponics,?EUR??,,????'?????<???????? vegetated mats and living fences all qualify as living walls.
Hydroponics was pioneered by Patrick Blanc, a French researcher, designer and tropical botanist. His system grows the plants without soil, using a balance of water and nutrients. In lieu of soil is a wool felt-like blanket for roots to take hold, a waterproof backing (PVC sheet) and drip irrigation to keep the felt wet. There is normally a pump to recirculate water collected at the base of the wall. If the plant selection is appropriate for the climate, maintenance is minimal, just annual clipping and removal of dead foliage.
Challenges Not all vegetated walls are easy to grow or maintain. Ms. Philips notes a recent failure for an interior moss wall at the California Academy of Sciences in San Francisco. They could not get the right mix of light and water nutrients, and so the moss wall was nixed before the museum opened. These walls, she says, are more water and resources dependent, use more energy and are more costly than other living wall types.
Another challenge for living walls are vegetation mats, a system used on green roofs that consists of drought-resistant sedums. Walls do not receive direct rainfall or direct sunlight and have to deal with direct wind. ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Add a thin layer of soil substrate and the additional shade effect on the lower portions of the wall and you have a less friendly plant environment than a roof top,?EUR??,,????'?????<???????? Ms. Philips explains. She warns that vertical sedum walls may look lush, but their long-term success is not guaranteed. She notes a succulent wall at Flora Grubb Nursery, which has inspired a thousand imitations in the past couple years, now looks tired and not so photogenic. The reason is the succulents move and ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????grow leggy?EUR??,,????'?????<???????? as they mature. Many of the succulents have moved from their initial planting spots and left vacant areas of substrate. She believes additional drip irrigation and pinning of the mats to hold soil and plants to the supporting structure may help prolong the life of matting systems. Some vegetation structures (Tourensol SiteWorks and Green Living Technologies) angle the support structures for the vegetation to get more sunlight and rain capture. ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Some of the companies with the modular systems allow designers, ecologists and landscape architects the ability to collaborate on the plant pallette to be used and some do not, keeping to more commercially viable alternatives to limit their liability exposure. In general, more collaboration will allow for greater biodiversity and habitat to be developed in these systems,?EUR??,,????'?????<???????? she adds.
The Focus Ms. Philips told LASN her focus now is on trying to look at the pros and cons of various systems before recommending them to clients. ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????I have had mixed results already due to the lack of information or understanding on the complexity of what these type of systems require for design/install/upkeep and want to be able to adapt my thinking/lessons learned for my future projects on the boards.?EUR??,,????'?????<????????
April Philips is currently doing a few vertical garden tests at her studio, as she receives modules from vendors. One installation is an edible garden at a middle school that uses ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Woolly Pockets.?EUR??,,????'?????<???????? Woolly Pockets are hanging containers from recycled plastic bottles to hold soil, compost and plants. The pockets will be hung onto a Woolly Pocket wall next to the kitchen as an edible vertical garden or living wall. April awaits the day when the kids will say, ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Let?EUR??,,????'?????<????????????EUR??,,??s eat the wall!?EUR??,,????'?????<????????
Addendum For ?EUR??,,????'?????<????????Fountains at Roseville?EUR??,,????'?????<???????? in the Aug. issue, we neglected to credit the Landscape Contractors for the project: Decker Landscaping - Rocklin, Calif. Pacific Parks Landscaping - Rocklin, Calif.
Raleigh, North Carolina
Francisco Uviña, University of New Mexico
Hardscape Oasis in Litchfield Park
Ash Nochian, Ph.D. Landscape Architect
Sign up to receive Landscape Architect and Specifier News Magazine, LA Weekly and More...
Invalid Verification Code
Please enter the Verification Code below
You are now subcribed to LASN. You can also search and download CAD files and spec sheets from LADetails.