Russ McConnell, public works director, explained that the project of weed removal by hand from Vista Park was too time-consuming and non-productive. He noted that Cochise County, Douglas, Benson and several other municipalities and the school districts used Round-Up to maintain weed-free areas. The only place in the city where the herbicide would be used would be in Vista Park.

A number of Bisbee residents, however spoke out against the use of herbicides citing health risks to children, unknown long-term dangers and the alleged toxic brew that can occur when Round-Up breaks down in certain types of soil.